Image of attorneys and staff at Brunvand Wise, P.A.

The Strong Defense
You Deserve

Text Us Now

What to Do When Facing Criminal Charges in Florida: Understanding Your Plea Options

by | Oct 12, 2023 | Criminal Law

If you or a loved one ever face criminal charges in Florida, one of the first decisions you’ll need to make is how to plead at your arraignment. While most people are familiar with the terms “guilty” and “not guilty,” the full array of plea options in Florida might surprise you.

Types of Pleas in Florida’s Criminal Justice System

When arraigned in Florida, a defendant has four primary plea options:

  1. Not Guilty
  2. Guilty
  3. No Contest (Nolo Contendere)
  4. Remain Mute

Each of these pleas carries significant implications, and it’s crucial to understand their nuances before deciding how to proceed. Often, the best course of action is to consult with an experienced Florida criminal defense attorney to evaluate your specific situation.

Decoding the “Not Guilty” Plea

In the age of social media and 24/7 news, it’s not uncommon for armchair detectives to prematurely determine a defendant’s guilt or innocence. However, our legal system operates on the fundamental principle of presumed innocence until proven guilty.

A “not guilty” plea essentially denies the crime in question. This plea doesn’t necessarily mean the defendant claims total innocence. Instead, it might reflect various strategic reasons like:

  • Negotiating a more favorable plea deal with the prosecution.
  • Needing more time to assess the evidence and case.
  • Awaiting legal counsel before making a final decision.

It’s crucial to remember that an initial “not guilty” plea can be changed later on, often based on evolving case dynamics and legal counsel.

Implications of a “Guilty” Plea

Pleading guilty is a clear admission of the crime. Such a plea often speeds up the court process, leading directly to sentencing. However, a guilty plea also waives numerous rights, such as:

  • The right to a trial (by jury or judge).
  • The right to challenge evidence or confront witnesses.
  • The right to appeal, in most cases.

Given the significant rights a defendant relinquishes with a guilty plea, it’s paramount to seek legal counsel before making such a decision.

The “No Contest” Plea Explained

A nolo contendere, or “no contest” plea, occupies a middle ground. Here, a defendant doesn’t admit guilt but also doesn’t challenge the charges. While the implications in the criminal justice system mirror those of a guilty plea, the defendant may prefer this option, especially when worried about potential civil lawsuits arising from the same incident.

Choosing to Remain Mute

If a defendant remains silent during arraignment, the court will automatically enter a “not guilty” plea on their behalf. This strategy can be beneficial in specific scenarios, but like all plea decisions, it’s best evaluated with an attorney’s guidance.

Seeking Expert Guidance is Key

Facing criminal charges can be daunting, with each decision potentially affecting one’s future. This is why consulting with an expert is invaluable. At Brunvand Wise P.A., we offer free consultations to guide those navigating Florida’s criminal justice system, ensuring they make informed choices every step of the way. Don’t face these challenges alone; reach out and equip yourself with experienced legal counsel.


FindLaw Network