Image of attorneys and staff at Brunvand Wise, P.A.

The Strong Defense
You Deserve

Text Us Now

Why Double Jeopardy Matters in Criminal Defense Law: A Deep Dive into Florida and Federal Criminal Cases

by | Oct 4, 2023 | Criminal Law

The legal arena is replete with principles designed to maintain justice. Among these principles, double jeopardy stands tall, ensuring that individuals are not unfairly tried twice for the same crime. As you venture deeper into the world of criminal defense law, particularly in Florida, it becomes evident just how vital this rule is.

Historical Context

From the vestiges of ancient Greek and Roman civilizations, the principle of double jeopardy emerges as a beacon of fairness. It found its firm footing in American jurisprudence through the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which was ratified in 1791, decreeing that no individual should “be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb” for the same offense.

Constitutional Provisions

Under the overarching umbrella of the U.S. Constitution, the Double Jeopardy Clause sits within the Fifth Amendment. This not only governs federal court scenarios but, through the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, extends its protective arm over state and local jurisdictions.

Florida, too, enshrines this right in its constitution under Article I, Section 9, ensuring that individuals within the state are not subjected to repeated jeopardy.

Statutory Framework

Moving from constitutional canopies to the statutory structure, the federal legal system has Rule 12 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, which grants defense against repeated prosecution for the same crime. Similarly, the state of Florida, through its Statute Section 775.021(4), echoes these sentiments, ensuring that individuals aren’t punished excessively or repeatedly for the same transgression.

“Double Jeopardy” Case Examples

Historical legal battles like Gavieres v. United States and Benton v. Maryland have paved the way for the modern interpretation of the double jeopardy principle. Closer to home, Florida’s legal topography was influenced by the landmark judgment in Valdes v. State, where the court prohibited retrials on lesser charges once a conviction is appealed and reversed.

Defenses and the Role of Criminal Defense Attorney

In this intricate web of laws and interpretations, a criminal defense attorney emerges as a pivotal figure. Their prowess in preemptively invoking the defense of double jeopardy can often lead to case dismissals. They can assess the potential overlaps between charges in different jurisdictions, determine the legality of a declared mistrial, and apply principles like “collateral estoppel”.

One must remember that legal battles aren’t always black and white. As observed in cases like United States v. Felix and the ‘dual sovereignty’ doctrine presented in Heath v. Alabama, the landscape of double jeopardy is layered and complex.

Seeking Legal Representation in Your Criminal Case?

The maze of double jeopardy law, with its nuances and intricacies, necessitates the presence of a seasoned professional by your side. Enter Brunvand Wise, P.A., a team of stalwart defense attorneys ready to safeguard your rights. Their prowess in Florida and Federal laws ensures that you receive unparalleled legal representation.

Facing potential double jeopardy? Fear not! With Brunvand Wise, P.A., by your side, you’re not alone in this battle. Reach out to them for a free consultation, and let them steer your case towards the best possible outcome.


FindLaw Network