Free Consultation Hablamos EspaƱol
Phone: 727-446-7505

Hearing Granted in Pinellas Babysitter Manslaughter Case

As reported in the Tampa Bay Times, a Pinellas-Pasco judge granted a hearing for Stephanie Spurgeon to determine if there is evidence to support a dismissal or new trial in a manslaughter case pending against her. Spurgeon, a Palm Harbor day care owner, argues that the state withheld evidence that could have changed the verdict.

Spurgeon's defense attorney, Bjorn Brunvand of this office, says the state violated the Brady rule, which requires the state in criminal cases to disclose to a defendant all evidence favorable to the defense. Spurgeon was convicted of manslaughter last month by a jury and awaits sentencing. She faces up to 15 years in prison for the death of a one-year-old in her care. Spurgeon was initially charged with first-degree murder. A jury convicted her instead of manslaughter.

The defense recently learned Pinellas County Medical Examiner Jon Thogmartin said another child at the day care could have caused the injuries that killed 1-year-old Maria Harris. Thogmartin made the statement to a law school class while lecturing. A student in the class reported the statements to defense counsel.

Thogmartin is expected to testify at the hearing.

In August 2008, Harris' grandmother dropped the child off at Spurgeon's home day care. When she picked up the child that afternoon, Maria was lethargic and soon became unresponsive. She died days later in the hospital. An autopsy determined the child died of blunt head trauma.

During the trial, 11 medical experts testified with differing opinions on what caused the injuries.

Brunvand and co-counsel Ron Kurpiers requested a meeting with Thogmartin to confirm the information. "We said this is the first we heard of that," Kurpiers said. "You didn't put it in your report. He emphasized to us that he had on multiple occasions relayed that information to the assistant state attorney."

The information never made it to the defense attorneys before or during the trial. The defense maintains that if the jury had been presented this critical evidence, it would have returned a finding of not guilty.

Prosecutors say they didn't hear Thogmartin discuss any new evidence and, if they had, they would have brought it to the court's attention.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • American inns of court
  • norml
  • National association of criminal defense lawyers
  • Clearwater bar association
  • Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

Let Us Help You

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Clearwater Office
615 Turner Street
Clearwater, FL 33756

Phone: 727-315-1685
Phone: (727) 446-7505
Fax: 727-446-8147
Clearwater Law Office Map

Tampa Office
902 N. Armenia Avenue
Tampa, FL 33609

Phone: 727-315-1685
Map & Directions

Please Direct All Correspondence to the Clearwater Office